The "R" Word

Published on February 2, 2004

There’s a valuable comparison to be found by slogging through this week’s New Yorker lead story (print only), by the normally-astute Jon Lee Anderson, on “the Shiite leader who says he can run Iraq” and The New York Times Magazine’s piece on “The Shiite Surge,” by the normally-gaseous David Rieff. But this time around Rieff gets the story, or at […]

There’s a valuable comparison to be found by slogging through this week’s New Yorker lead story (print only), by the normally-astute Jon Lee Anderson, on “the Shiite leader who says he can run Iraq” and The New York Times Magazine’s piece on “The Shiite Surge,” by the normally-gaseous David Rieff. But this time around Rieff gets the story, or at least quite a bit more of it than Anderson. What’s the difference? The “r-word,” as in “religion” — nearly absent from Anderson’s account, permeating Rieff’s more insightful report. “If the war seems distant,” Rieff writes of the Shiite holy cities of Najaf and Karbala, “God is everywhere.”

Explore 21 years and 4,096 articles of

The Revealer